ECG expertise when you want it, where you want it

ECG On-Demand News

Technomed wins High Court judgement that its database rights and copyright have been infringed by a competitor
Mark Hashemi / Tuesday, September 12, 2017 / Categories: Intellectual Property

Technomed wins High Court judgement that its database rights and copyright have been infringed by a competitor

Background

All resting ECG reports issued by Technomed's ECG On-Demand® service are produced using a proprietary 2-step process;

  1. Resting ECGs are classified by cardiac physiologists using a standardised ECG classification protocol.
  2. The physiologist classifications are then further processed using a risk classification algorithm calling on an underlying database to deliver the consensus triage opinion of a consultant cardiologist panel.
It was Technomed's case that a commercial competitor replicated Technomed's reports by copying Technomed's system.

Judgement


David Stone sitting as a judge of the High Court, Chancery Division, handed down his judgment on 24 Aug 2017.

The judge found that for a period of 3 years, a commercial competitor together with another party had infringed Technomed's intellectual property rights by copying substantial parts of Technomed’s ECG On-Demand® (formally ECG Cloud®) ECG reporting system. Of particular concern to Technomed was the replication of their ECG risk stratification and report generation database, a critical component of ECG On-Demand®, which Technomed has invested substantially in.

The judge found:

"There has been substantial investment in the obtaining and verification and presentation of the contents of the Database, assessed qualitatively. Technomed has sought to prevent extraction and/or re-utilisation of the whole or a substantial part of the contents of the Database. In my judgment, sui generis database right subsists in the Database."

"[The defendants] submission may have had greater force if in fact [they] had not used [Technomed's database] as a database. However … not only did [they] copy the entire database but they also electronically accessed the contents of the database,"

 

The case has been widely reported in the legal press gaining coverage for the effective use of database rights to protect a medical computer application and in what formats a database can exist in.

Comment

Mark Hashemi, managing director of Technomed commented, “We are very proud of our ECG On-Demand® reporting system and have spent a very considerable amount of time developing it. It is therefore particularly important to us to be able to protect our intellectual investment. This judgment demonstrates that we are able to do so if required.

It was very flattering that our competitor copied us however we would have preferred if they had not done so, thus avoiding the litigation.”

Print
Rate this article:
4.2
454

Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:
x

What our customers say

We provide Primary Care Cardiology services to 65 GP surgeries in the central Manchester area. We rely on ECG On-Demand® for our Holter analysis service.
Our patients like the discreet Holter recorders and the ECG recordings and report quality is excellent. ECG On-Demand’s 12-lead service provides a smart ECG machine that provides a better quality recording and halves the number number of ECGs sent to us for review.

Dr Washik Parkar - GPwSI
Heart Networks, Manchester

Get in Touch